Thursday, November 16, 2006

Prem gives Churchill a bad name

Following Anan Panyarachun's allegation that New Zealand/Australia are ignorant and not understanding of the tradition of the COUP in Thailand, we have a new gaffe made by another former Prime Minister, Prem Tinsulanonda . ( NOTICE : they both were PM during the military rule, neither were elected by Thai population)

Now Prem's reference to Winston Churchill has become a talk of the cyber town. He gave an analogy between Winston Churchill's rise to power and that of Gen. Surayut of Thailand.

From Thairath website it can be translated into


"every Thai citizen must have the duty of creating National conciliation, sacrificing for the national rather than personal interest and withholding the lowly, vulgar thoughts. Everyone must know of Mr.Winston Churchill who was the prime minister of England during the WW II just like Gen.Surayut is being a PM of Thailand as of now. They both have the same paths that they neither were elected by the people (MPs). Churchill was being invited to be a Prime Minister because the Queen saw that he had appropriate qualities. And Churchill also talked about the necessity of sacrificing for the country in his famous speech. Gen Suruyut of Thailand, in the same manner as Churchill, has accepted the post of PM not because he wants to but because he sacrifices himself to the country"

"the WW II occurred because of the power greed of less than 10 people. These 10 people engaged the world into war for many years because they wanted power. I really don’t understand why people are hungry for power (implied: because I don’t, albeit my 8 years of PMship)." Prem says.

Thai Coup Watch's COMMENTS : Had Gen. Prem known the history of England more he would not have said such statement. Why ?

1. Churchill was elected by the populace, he was a politician under the English parliamentary system.

2. With the concensus from the parliament. King George VI, not the Queen, asked Churchill to be a PM and to form an all party government.

3. How can Prem compare the leader from military coup to the English stateman during WW II like Churchil ? Does he want to justify the coup or to promote Suyayud who is known as Prem's puppet PM ?

4. Someone also suggested that this part of history is well-written in the King Bhumipol- translated book titled 'The Man Called Interprid". So it is quite likely that the head of Privy Council might never read this famed book by the King at all.

This will be another memorable quote made by Gen.Prem. Lately, he has made some analogies to 'Jockey, Horse and Owner' in explaining the role of the military, the government and the king. Another one is when he implicitly compared Thaksin to 'Hitler' . I wonder what more would come from this once-known-as-a very quiet PM.

P.S. I have just discovered that BangkokPundit already covered this very same issue. And it also appeared in the nation.


Further readings:

Winston Churchill - wikipedia
Blood toil tears and sweat - the famous quote of Churchill

7 Comments:

At 8:18 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

16 November 2006
Thailand

To Mr. Tony Blair Prime Minister of England,

General Prem Tinsulanonda, President of the Privy Council, a prominent personage prior to the coup d’etat whose role becomes more pronounced since the coup d’etat on 19 September 2006, made a speech at King Mongut’s Institute of Technology Ladkrabang on 15 November 2006.

“All Thais have the responsibility to promote harmony within the country by following these steps: the necessity to adhere to two main sacrifices, sacrificing for the whole proceeds personal gain and sacrificing morally base thoughts of the mind. Everyone must know of Mr. Winston Churchill, a Prime Minister like Khun Surayud. He was the Prime Minister of England during World War II. Both were not elected by the people but were appointed to act a PM because the Queen’s acknowledgement of suitability for the position. Mr. Churchill mentioned sacrifice in a statement in English to stress the necessity of sacrifice for the benefit of the country. Our PM Surayud also has accepted the PM position without intending to, but accepted the PM position for the benefit of the country. Churchill stated during WWII that WWII started because of the need for power from less than ten individuals and that these ten individuals ignited the whole world to go to war for many years because of their need for power. For this reason, I do not know how attracting power is to induce people to need power. When I was appointed PM, I did not feel that power was the instrument to induce me to act upon any certain direction; but in retrospect, I feel that I should not hold too much power”.

We feel that General Prem Tinsulanonda’s speech is false as well as inappropriate as he compares a PM appointed from the coup d’etat, in which is unaccepted by the general Thai population, to a former PM Winston Churchill, a great leader in England, who battled Nazis with victory in WWII. But, PM General Surayud Chulanont, in Thailand, is different because his battle is with the unarmed Thai citizens as he hides behind the martial law in order to force the unarmed Thai population under his thumb to the present day.

We would like the PM of England to be informed that General Prem Tinsulanonda’s comparison of Sir Winston Churchill to the present PM General Surayud Chulanont is an act of degrading a great leader to be inappropriate on General Prem Tinsulanonda’s part.

Many Thais do not agree with General Prem Tinsulanonda’s comparison between former appointed PM, Sir Winston Churchill, and present military coup appointed PM, General Surayud Chulanont. We are sorry that your former PM is soiled by General Prem Tinsulanonda’s effort to promote his associates and cohorts, who robbed democracy from the Thai people, as a great leader like Sir Winston Churchill.

With respect from Thai people

 
At 9:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Churchill is a great wartime leader, but he is also only mortal and not without flaws.

I don't think it's really a stretch for someone to compare whoever to Churchill. The tone of the previous post makes it sounds like a sacrilege to compare Surayud to Churchill, as if Winston is some kind of deity.

From an Anglo-Saxon perspective, it might be justified to view Churchill as an all-around hero, and that's probably the popular discourse that we hear all the time. Yet this belies the fact that Churchill is only a product of his own time, an elitist,and a staunch imperialist to boot. In his own words, "I have not become the King's first Minister to preside over the liquidation of the British Empire". His point of view on class relations and colonialism is antiquated, and in fact, he was soundly defeated in an election at the end of the war he just won.

 
At 1:30 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

TREATMENT IMPOTENCE
BUY CHEAP CIALIS ONLINE
BUY LOW-COST VIAGRA ! HALF-PRICE CIALIS ! CHEAP LEVITRA !
BUY CHEAP VIAGRA ONLINE

 
At 3:14 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

LOW-COST CIALIS

BUY LOW-PRICES CIALIS LEVITRA VIAGRA ANTIDEPRESSANTs...!!!
WOMAN VIAGRA
DISCOUNT CHEAP VIAGRA.DYSFUNCTION ERECTILE NEW MEDS
BUY CHEAP CIALIS
BUY CHEAP CIALIS ONLINE...ORDER LOW-COST VIAGRA & SAVE 60% of YOUR MONEY
BUY LOW-COST VIAGRA ! HALF-PRICE CIALIS ! CHEAP LEVITRA !

BUY HALF-PRICE VIAGRA.DYSFUNCTION ERECTILE NEW MEDS
ACNE MEDICINE ONLINE
CHEAP ACCUTANE ONLINE
WHAT IS ANTHELMINTICS

what is Albenza ?
ANTIBACTERIAL MEDICINE & CARE
buy low-cost amoxil
AMPICILLIN ONLINE
BUY AMPICILLIN
BUY CHEAP BACTRIM
buy bactim
NEW DRUGS & PILLS… SUPER-VIAGRA…
LOW-COST CIALIS
BUY CIPRO ONLINE

cipro mg
BUY CHEAP DIFLUCAN ONLINE
BUY HALF-PRICE DIFLUCAN ONLINE
BUY CHEAP SUPER VIAGRA ONLINE AND SAVE 70 % OF MONEY...
BUY VIAGRA FOR MEN & WOMEN WITHOUT PRESCRIPTION
BUSINESS CREDIT CARDS ONLINE

 
At 10:23 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...



Lοok into my blog poѕt payday loans

 
At 7:42 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

She also wanted to know if these work better or sooner than the pregnancy tests that you can get from any pHarmacy or grocery store. Have you ever thought about why it is more difficult to have pregnant right after forty than after we were young, say within our early to 20s?
http://pregnancyhelper.in/fertility-statistics.html

 
At 4:11 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

helpful information Because the report previously listed, make sure that you question the proper queries about your future health insurance insurance coverage. Payment is made to the veterinarian at the time of service, and then a claim is submitted to the ASPCA via email, fax, or mail.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home